The Essential Checklist for Evaluating Your Company’s Website

Your company’s website serves as the front door to your business for potential customers around the globe. It’s not just an online business card but a salesperson, a customer service rep, and your brand’s ambassador, all rolled into one. A well-designed and functional website is crucial not just for delivering a stellar user experience, but it’s also vital for conversion, customer retention, and even SEO. Simply put, your website can make or break your business’s success.

Given the significance, how do you know if your website is actually performing at its best? That’s exactly what we aim to address in this blog post. We’ve compiled an essential checklist designed to help you comprehensively evaluate your company’s website, so you can identify areas of excellence and opportunities for improvement. Whether you’re a marketer, an executive, or a business owner, this guide is designed to give you the tools you need to ensure your website is in tip-top shape.

The Importance of Website Evaluation

Just like you wouldn’t ignore regular maintenance on a physical storefront or office, your website also requires consistent check-ups to ensure it’s running smoothly. Here’s why regular audits are not just a good practice, but essential for your website’s optimal performance:

Why Regular Audits Are Crucial

  1. Stay Ahead of the Competition: Everything is always evolving. Regular audits allow you to adapt quickly and stay ahead of competitors who are slower to update.
  2. Optimize User Experience: User behaviors and expectations change over time. By regularly evaluating your website, you can fine-tune the user experience, making it easier for visitors to find what they’re looking for and take action.
  3. SEO Benefits: Search engines love up-to-date, fully-functional websites. Regular audits can help you maintain or improve your search engine rankings, making it easier for new customers to find you.
  4. Identify & Fix Issues: Nothing tarnishes a brand’s reputation faster than a broken website. Regular checks help you catch issues before they deter potential customers.

The Consequences of Neglect

Ignoring regular website maintenance can lead to a range of problems:

  1. Loss of Credibility: An outdated or broken website signals a lack of professionalism, causing you to lose credibility in the eyes of potential customers.
  2. Decreased Traffic: As your website becomes outdated, it’s likely to fall in search engine rankings, leading to decreased visibility and less traffic.
  3. Security Risks: Older websites are more vulnerable to security breaches, putting both your business and your customers at risk.
  4. Reduced Conversion Rates: If your website doesn’t offer a smooth user experience, visitors are less likely to convert into customers, leads, or subscribers, directly impacting your bottom line.

Usability and Design

When visitors land on your website, they’re looking for a seamless, intuitive experience. Below are some key factors to consider in this regard. These elements are essential for both user satisfaction and your website’s overall performance.

Mobile Responsiveness

Why It’s Important

More than half of all web traffic comes from mobile devices. If your website isn’t mobile-friendly, you’re essentially ignoring a large chunk of your potential audience, and you might even be penalized by search engines like Google.

How to Test

There are various ways to test mobile responsiveness:

  • Manual Testing: Simply open your website on different devices and browsers to see how it performs.
  • Google’s Mobile-Friendly Test: This online tool provides a quick way to assess mobile compatibility.

Loading Speed

Importance for SEO and UX

Slow-loading pages can lead to high bounce rates, lower user engagement, and a drop in search engine rankings. Fast-loading pages, on the other hand, improve user experience and can contribute positively to SEO.

Tools to Measure Speed

  • Google PageSpeed Insights: Provides insights into what’s slowing your page down and how to improve it.
  • GTmetrix: Another robust tool that offers actionable recommendations.


Importance of a User-Friendly Menu

A confusing or cluttered navigation menu can frustrate visitors and lead them to exit your website. A well-structured, intuitive menu makes it easy for visitors to find the information they’re looking for, improving their overall experience.

Common Pitfalls

  • Too Many Options: A cluttered menu can overwhelm users.
  • Unclear Labels: Use straightforward language that your audience understands.
  • Lack of Hierarchy: Important links should be more prominent and easy to find.

Content Quality

Great design and fast load times are vital, but what keeps users engaged and coming back for more is high-quality content. This section delves into the key aspects you should consider when evaluating your website’s content.


Target Audience Needs

Understand who your target audience is and what they want. The content you provide should solve a problem they have, answer a question, or fulfill a need.

Updating Outdated Content

The internet is a fast-paced environment. Information that was relevant last year may not hold the same value today. Regularly review and update your content to ensure it’s still useful and relevant.


Importance of Text Layout

A wall of text can be overwhelming and uninviting. Use headers, bullet points, and short paragraphs to break up text and make it easier to read.

Font and Color Considerations

Choose fonts and colors that are easy on the eyes and that fit with your brand’s overall aesthetic. Make sure there is enough contrast between text and background colors for readability.

Calls to Action (CTAs)

Importance for Conversion

A well-placed and well-worded CTA can guide visitors towards taking a desired action, whether it’s making a purchase, signing up for a newsletter, or getting in touch.

Placement and Wording

  • Placement: Position CTAs where they naturally fit within the user’s browsing flow. Avoid disrupting the user experience with overly aggressive or misplaced CTAs.
  • Wording: Be concise and specific. Instead of a generic “Click Here,” use action-oriented language like “Get Started,” “Learn More,” or “Contact Us.”

SEO (Search Engine Optimization)

A well-designed website isn’t just about the user; it’s also about how easily search engines can discover and rank your pages. Proper SEO practices are instrumental in driving organic traffic to your site. Let’s dig into some key elements you should be focusing on.

Meta Descriptions and Titles

Their Role in SEO

Meta descriptions and titles act as the “elevator pitch” for your website in search engine results. They help both search engines and users understand what a specific page is about, impacting click-through rates and rankings.

Best Practices

  • Length: Keep meta titles under 60 characters and descriptions under 160.
  • Relevance: Ensure the meta title and description accurately reflect the content of the page.
  • Keywords: Include target keywords but don’t stuff; it should read naturally.

Keyword Usage

Importance in Ranking

Keywords are the search terms that people use to find content online. Proper keyword usage helps search engines understand your content and rank it appropriately.

Overstuffing Pitfalls

Excessive use of keywords can result in penalties from search engines and a poor user experience. The key is to use keywords naturally within the content.


Role in Website Authority

Backlinks, or inbound links from other reputable websites, act as endorsements, telling search engines that your content is valuable and authoritative.

Quality Over Quantity

It’s better to have a few backlinks from high-quality, reputable websites than many from low-quality sites. Quality backlinks can significantly boost your site’s authority and rankings.

Technical Aspects

In an age where data breaches and hacking attempts are increasingly common, the technical aspects of your website can’t be ignored. Moreover, analyzing performance data provides valuable insights for optimization. Let’s break down these elements.


SSL Certificates

An SSL (Secure Sockets Layer) certificate is essential for protecting your website and your customers. It encrypts data sent between the user and the server, enhancing trust and security. Most search engines also consider SSL as a ranking factor.

Data Protection Measures

Regularly update your website’s software and plugins, and make sure you have solid security measures like a web application firewall (WAF) and malware scanning in place. Always keep backups of your website so you can quickly recover in case of a breach.


Importance of Tracking Performance

You can’t manage what you can’t measure. Analytics tools provide invaluable data on user behavior, site performance, and more, helping you make data-driven decisions.

Recommended Tools

  • Google Analytics: The go-to tool for tracking various metrics like user behavior, conversion rates, and sources of traffic.
  • Hotjar or Crazy Egg: These tools offer heatmaps and user recordings to give you insights into how users interact with your site.
  • SEMrush or Ahrefs: For more in-depth SEO analytics and competitive research.


From the usability and design aspects like mobile responsiveness and loading speed to the technical elements such as security and analytics, a well-rounded website requires careful attention to a variety of factors. Don’t forget the importance of high-quality, relevant content and SEO best practices to make sure your site ranks well and meets the needs of your audience.

A proactive approach to website evaluation will not only enhance user experience but also positively impact your business metrics, from SEO rankings to conversion rates. Take time to go through this checklist, fine-tune your website, and keep it in top shape to ensure it serves your business effectively.

We hope you find this checklist valuable. Remember, a website is not a “set it and forget it” type of asset; it requires ongoing care to perform at its best. So, make it a habit to audit your website regularly, ensuring it remains a powerful tool for your business.

Free Website Audit

Is your website at its best? Our free website audit will guide you through boosting performance and wowing your visitors.

More To Explore

What Are SEO Backlinks?

Backlinks are vital for SEO success. Understand what they are and how to build them effectively to enhance your website’s search rankings and credibility.

Have a project you'd like to discuss?
Reach out today

Fill out the form, and we’ll contact you within one business day to discuss your project. You can also call us at (360) 450-3711 and we'll pick up.

Graticle delivered where their competitors didn't. I have now used them for multiple companies on both the website development side and for SEO with exemplary results. I highly recommend!
Joshua D.
Entrepreneur in Vancouver, WA


Of customers served in 15+ years in business

Fill this out and we’ll be in touch quickly.

"*" indicates required fields

Send us a quick message

Count on a friendly reply from our crew within the next business day. Looking forward to chatting with you! 🎉